North of the Highway

North of Montauk Highway, Water Mill takes on a different but equally appealing character. Open farmland, horse properties, and winding country roads define this side of the hamlet. Properties here sit on larger lots and offer a quieter, more rural lifestyle while remaining minutes from the village. Renovated farmhouses and newer construction homes in this area typically fall between $2 million and $5 million. Equestrian estates with paddocks, barns, and a creage can go considerably higher depending on the scale of the operation

‍