Sag Harbor Village Core

The village core is where the walkability, the history, and the premium pricing all converge. Homes on streets like Division Street, Suffolk Street, and Glover Street sit within easy reach of Main Street, the waterfront, and Mashashimuet Park. Renovated historic homes for sale in Sag Harbor typically trade between $3 million and $5 million. A fully renovated six-bedroom on Division Street, originally built in 1885, sold for $4.795 million in early 2025 after a two-year renovation. Smaller cottages and properties needing work begin closer to $2 million. The village core suits buyers who want to walk out the frontdoor and be somewhere.

‍